Imagine a shop where the prices aren't on display, the signs use jargon only used by the staff and the tills are round the back. Nothing's broken. But you'd probably still walk out, wouldn't you?
And this is the same for most websites. Bugs get flagged and fixed because they're blockers and therefore get noticed quickly (hopefully). The real killer is friction: small moments where a customer hesitates, gets confused or loses confidence. Taken in isolation, none of them seem worth fixing, but combine them over a customer journey and it's death by a thousand cuts.
Nobody raises a ticket for friction, because technically everything works. So it just sits there, making the experience harder than it needs to be.
And that's what a UX audit is for. It puts the prices back on the shelves, swaps the jargon for words your customers actually use, and moves the till to where people expect it. In other words: the right information, in the right place, at the right moment, with a clear route to purchase.
Here's a quick version you can run on your own site today, and a look at how we approach a more in-depth review.
The UX Audit Checklist
Our full audit asks 98 questions: 14 at each of seven stages, looked at through two lenses. Usability asks whether people can do it. Behaviour asks whether the experience gives them the confidence and motivation to want to. Each question is rooted in a named UX or behavioural principle, so every finding has a rationale behind it, rather than just being someone's opinion.
Below are three from each stage, the ones worth checking first. Grab your phone for this one. Friction is often more noticeable on a small screen, where there's less room for things to go wrong.
Homepage
- Could a first-time visitor say what you sell and who it's for, in five seconds?
- Is there one obvious next step, or are five messages fighting for attention?
- Can people see why they should trust you (reviews, guarantees, names they recognise) without scrolling to the footer?
Why it matters: Processing fluency. The easier something is to understand, the more comfortable people feel engaging with it. If visitors have to work too hard to understand what you offer, they're less likely to stick around.
Navigation
- Do menu labels use your customers' words, not your internal ones?
- Can people always tell where they are, and get back?
- Are your most popular things where people look first, on mobile too?
Why it matters: Information scent. People follow the words and cues that suggest they'll find what they're looking for. If the language doesn't match what's in their head, they may assume you don't offer it at all.
Search
- Does search cope with typos, synonyms and plurals?
- Do suggestions appear as people type, and do they actually help?
- When there are no results, is there still a way forward?
Why it matters: Error recovery. Searchers often know exactly what they're looking for, so they're frequently among your most motivated visitors. A search that leads to a dead end, rather than helping someone recover, can quickly lose them.
Category
- Do filters match how customers actually choose (size, price, date, location)?
- Can people see price, stock and key details without clicking in?
- Can a combination of filters leave people with nothing, and no obvious way back?
Why it matters: Choice overload. Too many options, without an easy way to narrow them down, can make decisions harder. Good filters help people move from browsing to finding what they're actually interested in.
Product
- Are price, availability and delivery clear without hunting?
- Are the common worries (returns, sizing, cancellation) answered on the page?
- Is there enough proof, like reviews and real photos, to feel sure?
Why it matters: Ambiguity aversion. When information is missing, people are more likely to delay making a decision. If someone isn't sure about sizing, delivery or returns, even a product they really want can become a "maybe later".
Basket
- Is the full cost, including delivery and fees, clear before checkout?
- Is it easy to change a quantity, remove an item or keep shopping?
- Is the reassurance (returns, secure payment, delivery dates) right next to the button, where the doubt is?
Why it matters: Expectation management. People build an expectation of what something will cost as they shop. Unexpected fees or delivery charges at the basket stage create a negative surprise and can undermine a decision they've already made.
Checkout
- Can people check out as a guest?
- Are you only asking for what you genuinely need?
- Do error messages say exactly what's wrong and how to fix it?
Why it matters: Cognitive load. Every extra field, decision or unclear instruction is one more thing to think about, just when people are most focused on completing their purchase. The simpler the process, the easier it is to keep moving.
That's just 21. Here's what the other 77 cover…
The rest go deeper: visual hierarchy and what people actually notice, how much effort each step really takes, whether the site behaves consistently across pages and devices, how well it motivates people to carry on, and whether the promises made early on hold up all the way to the till.
Because good UX isn't just about whether someone can complete a task. It's about how easy, intuitive and reassuring you make it along the way.
A checklist is just the starting point
A checklist is a great way to start looking at your website differently. It helps you spot things you might otherwise overlook and gives you a structured way to think about the experience from your customer's perspective.
But there's a difference between identifying potential friction and understanding what's actually happening.
A checklist can't tell you how many people are experiencing a particular issue, why they're struggling or whether something that looks like a problem is actually affecting their behaviour.
For that, you need to look a little deeper.
Combining a hands-on review with analytics, search data, competitor research and user testing can reveal a much more complete picture of the experience. It can also uncover opportunities that a checklist alone would never identify.
We've written more about how to take a UX audit beyond the checklist, including the different techniques and data sources we use to challenge assumptions and uncover opportunities.
You may also be interested in
How We Use AI to Run More Impactful Testing Programmes
Read more about AI in CRO: How We Use AI to Run More Impactful Testing Programmes
Moderated vs Unmoderated User Testing: Which Should You Use?
Read more about Moderated vs Unmoderated User Testing: Which Should You Use?
What Is User Testing? Methods, Benefits and When to Use It
Read more about What Is User Testing? Methods, Benefits and When to Use It
Why CRO Needs a Human-Centred Approach in the Age of AI
As AI continues to shape how websites are built and optimised, Conversion Rate Optimisation (CRO) is becoming increasingly standardised. We advocate for putting the customer, and human, first.
The Pros and Cons of AI for CRO Development
It's hard to find a corner of the tech world that generative AI hasn't reached. "Should we use AI here?" has quietly become "where shouldn't we?", and AI code has quickly evolved from a joke into standard industry practice.