A UX checklist is a great place to start. It gives you a structured way to look at your website, spot potential friction and question things you might otherwise overlook.
In our previous blog, we shared 21 questions you can use to review your own website, covering seven stages of the customer journey, from homepage to checkout.
But identifying potential issues is only the first step. A checklist can't tell you how many people are affected, why they're struggling or whether something that looks like a problem is actually influencing their behaviour.
To get a more complete picture, you need to look beyond the interface itself. That means combining different data sources, research techniques and perspectives to understand not just what might be wrong, but what's actually happening.
Here are some of the approaches we use to take a UX audit further.
1. Walk through the experience yourself
We always start by walking through a website as a customer before opening a single report.
It's tempting to start with the analytics and let the numbers tell you where to look. But doing that can mean you only investigate the things you already know about.
Walking through the experience first gives you a fresh perspective. You start to notice the small things that might otherwise go under the radar: unclear messaging, unexpected interactions, missing information or moments where you have to stop and think about what to do next.
And don't just follow the ideal journey. Try taking a few wrong turns, changing your mind, using search instead of navigation or going back a step. Sometimes the most interesting friction appears when things don't go exactly to plan.
2. Bring in the analytics
A walk-through might highlight friction on a particular page or step in the customer journey, but how significant is it? How many people are affected, and what does that behaviour actually mean for the business?
This is where analytics helps put things into perspective.
Using GA4, we can quantify how people move through the website, understand key journeys and identify where behaviour changes. We look beyond overall conversion rates to understand differences by device, channel, market, new versus returning visitors and other audience segments.
This helps us to start sizing the opportunity. Rather than simply saying a page could be improved, we can understand how many people use it, how they behave and where improvements could make the biggest difference. "The basket could be better" becomes "every 1% recovered here on mobile is worth £X a year".
3. Understand user intent
Search Console shows what people typed into Google before they landed on your website.
This gives us another perspective on what customers expect to find, and whether the page they're arriving on actually delivers it.
For example, if someone searches "walking boots free delivery" and lands on a page that doesn't mention delivery, the friction starts before they've even scrolled.
It also highlights opportunities to improve the connection between SEO and UX. Getting someone onto your website is only half the job. The experience needs to deliver on the expectation that brought them there.
4. Look beyond your own website
Your customers don't just visit your website. They compare. Competitor benchmarking helps us understand what people might already expect from an online experience, as well as where there might be opportunities to do things differently.
If everyone else shows delivery costs upfront and you don't, that's a gap to close fast. If you do something nobody else does, that's an edge worth shouting about.
But benchmarking isn't about copying what everyone else does. Just because a competitor has something doesn't mean it's right for your customers.
It's about understanding the wider landscape, identifying common expectations and spotting opportunities to stand out.
5. Look for what's missing
Not every UX issue is something that's broken or needs fixing. Sometimes the biggest opportunities come from what's missing altogether.
A product page might have all the essential information, but could a comparison tool help someone choose? Would a video demonstration answer questions that product photography can't? Could a way to save products for later make the experience more useful?
These aren't necessarily fixes. They're ideas worth exploring to make the experience better.
The question isn't always "What's making this harder?" Sometimes it's "What could make this better?"
6. Get another perspective
It's easy to become familiar with a website and overlook things that would confuse someone seeing it for the first time.
That's why user testing and fresh eyes are so valuable.
We use short user studies with real users to understand how they interact with the site, where they hesitate, what they misunderstand and what they're thinking as they move through different journeys.
Watching someone try to complete a task can reveal things that analytics alone never will. You might see someone repeatedly overlook a button, misunderstand a product description or struggle to find information that you assumed was obvious.
Know what to do with your findings
Once you've brought all these different perspectives together, the next challenge is deciding what to do with them.
Not a long list of problems, but a plan.
Every finding is scored on its impact, the evidence behind it and the revenue at stake. It then goes into one of three piles:
- Fix it: clear problems with strong evidence. Just get them done.
- Test it: promising ideas where the answer isn't obvious. Run an A/B test.
- Find out first: questions the data can't answer. Ask real users.
In our experience, plenty of "test it" ideas turn out clear enough to just fix. That's weeks saved waiting on tests.
You may also be interested in
How We Use AI to Run More Impactful Testing Programmes
Read more about AI in CRO: How We Use AI to Run More Impactful Testing Programmes
Moderated vs Unmoderated User Testing: Which Should You Use?
Read more about Moderated vs Unmoderated User Testing: Which Should You Use?
What Is User Testing? Methods, Benefits and When to Use It
Read more about What Is User Testing? Methods, Benefits and When to Use It
Why CRO Needs a Human-Centred Approach in the Age of AI
As AI continues to shape how websites are built and optimised, Conversion Rate Optimisation (CRO) is becoming increasingly standardised. We advocate for putting the customer, and human, first.